The Fine Print of Periods
For fifteen years, Lakeview High School in St. Clair Shores, Michigan, has maintained a physical education policy governing female students’ participation in swimming lessons during menstruation. As outlined in the school’s gym class syllabus, female students seeking to obtain an exemption are required to provide a “written email/note from a parent stating the length of the menstrual duration.”
Presented as an “opportunity to make up days,” the accommodation permits “dry land workouts” in substitution of the swimming lessons. Yet, regardless of whether female students participate in the prescribed alternative activities—as the syllabus emphasizes that “[s]tudents will not just sit out“—failure to comply with the menstruation disclosure policy results in grade penalties. In the absence of comparable obligations for male students, this requirement imposes a sex-specific burden that raises serious concerns under Title IX’s prohibition against sex-based discrimination.
Title IX
Lakeview High School is governed by Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972. Under Title IX, “[n]o person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any academic, extracurricular, research, occupational training, or other education program or activity operated by a recipient . . .” of federal funding.
Identical treatment, however, is not necessarily the touchstone of Title IX. As the Department of Justice’s Office of Legal Counsel has indicated, not all sex-based distinctions constitute unlawful discrimination under the statute. Particularly where genuine biological differences are concerned, differential treatment may be permissible; Title IX does not demand equal treatment in all respects.
That latitude, however, is not without limits. In the Title IX context, several courts have embraced the Supreme Court’s interpretation of sex discrimination under Title VII in Bostock v. Clayton County, recognizing discrimination where individuals are treated worse than or inferior to those similarly situated.
Lakeview High School does provide an alternative to swimming lessons for students who abstain because of menstruation: “dry land workouts.” Yet the availability of an alternative activity does not resolve the separate inequity created by the school’s disclosure requirement. By conditioning exemption from swimming lessons on documentation of menstrual duration, the school imposes unique, additional burdens on female students, particularly the disclosure of intimate health information and the potential for academic penalties. Male students face no comparable disclosure obligations or threats to their grades.
The disclosure requirement’s resulting disparity effectively treats female students worse than their similarly situated male classmates. Even when female students participate in the alternative activities prescribed by the school, their ability to receive academic credit is contingent on the disclosure itself. The concern is not simply that the school offers different activities, but that female students must face additional obstacles for a biological process distinct to them, to receive a comparable educational experience.
Broader Implications and Reevaluation
Beyond the policy’s potential legal implications, consideration should also be given to the underlying message this policy conveys to female students about their bodies. Requiring documentation of menstrual duration implicitly treats students’ accounts of their own bodies as insufficient, placing the burden on them to substantiate a normal biological process through external verification. Such policies perpetuate the idea that menstruation is an excuse to be scrutinized rather than a legitimate physical experience, insinuating that students are exaggerating their discomfort, attempting to evade participation, or undeserving of accommodation in the first place.
This presumption is particularly harmful given the realities of menstruation during adolescence. Menstrual cycles vary in timing, duration, and symptoms, and the physical discomfort can be debilitating. More often than not, a student’s experience will not adhere to a predictable schedule, and the question of how long bleeding lasts becomes far too simplistic. Rather than accounting for the unpredictability of menstruation, Lakeview High School takes a back seat and forces female students to navigate that uncertainty alone.
The result is an unwinnable situation. Female students who disclose their menstruation risk embarrassment and the unwanted exposure of intimate health information. Those who decline to disclose face grade penalties despite participating in the prescribed alternative activities. Others may feel pressured to swim regardless, potentially compromising their bodily autonomy by using menstrual products they are not otherwise comfortable with.
Regardless, participation and nonparticipation are visible to classmates; neither option truly allows students to navigate menstruation with privacy and dignity. This reality invites a reconsideration of physical education’s relationship with menstruation. Rather than requiring students to justify their menstruation or participate in a predetermined alternative that may itself single out female students, schools should consider more flexible and inclusive approaches to participation that respect students’ privacy and individual circumstances. Reconsideration of these policies, therefore, extends beyond compliance with Title IX. We should expect more from our schools.
Reilly Werkhoven
Class of 2028, Staff Member