Two Paths to the Same Injustice: Sterilization in North Carolina and Puerto Rico
Two Systems of Reproductive Control
Between 1929 and 1974, North Carolina sterilized approximately 7,600 people under its eugenics program. By the mid-1970s, roughly thirty-five percent of women in Puerto Rico had been sterilized – a rate over ten times higher than that of women living in the fifty states. Sterilization became so widespread on the island that the procedure became commonly known as La Operación. These figures reveal profound losses of reproductive autonomy in both places, but those outcomes were produced through incredibly different systems of governmental control.
North Carolina relied on a centralized administrative system. Social workers petitioned a state board, which formally approved individual sterilizations. Puerto Rico relied on a broader network of family-planning policies, medical institutions, and population-control efforts. Together, these policies helped make sterilization extraordinarily common on the island.
The contrasting sterilization systems illustrate two forms of state power: reproductive control can operate through direct state action or through the creation of policies that can severely constrain reproductive choice.
North Carolina: Coercion by Petition
In 1933, the General Assembly created the Eugenics Board, which could authorize sterilization of people classified as feebleminded, mentally ill, epileptic, or otherwise considered unfit to reproduce. Although the program initially focused largely on people confined to state institutions, North Carolina eventually extended its program beyond institutions, allowing local welfare officials and social workers to initiate sterilization petitions for people living outside of state institutions. This structure gave local officials substantial power over vulnerable North Carolinians. A social worker or county welfare agency could investigate an individual, assemble a social and medical history, and bring the case before the Board. The Board would then determine whether sterilization should proceed.
Over time, the program increasingly targeted people whose perceived unfitness was tied to poverty rather than institutionalization. While gender always appeared to have played a role in determining who was targeted, the racial makeup of victims changed over the years. The early years of the program focused on low-income White women, while Black women were targeted in the later years of the program. Women constituted roughly eighty-five percent of those sterilized, with nonwhite North Carolinians, primarily Black residents, making up forty percent of those sterilizations.
North Carolina’s own Eugenics Study Committee later found that the program shifted toward public assistance recipients as traditional eugenic theory lost credibility. For some of these women, the distinction between consent and coercion became especially blurry. Nial Cox Ramirez, who was sterilized as a teenager in the 1960s, later testified that officials threatened her family’s welfare assistance if she refused sterilization. Her experience illustrates how the welfare system itself was used to pressure women into sterilization.
North Carolina left behind more than just victims; it also left a documented paper trail. There were petitions, hearings, orders, and individual case files documenting how reproductive decisions became government decisions. That paper trial later made it possible to identify victims, assign responsibility, and create a compensation system for the victims.
Puerto Rico: Reproductive Control through Constrained Choice
In 1937, Puerto Rico enacted Law 116, which legalized sterilization for contraceptive and eugenic purposes. Around that same time, the government expanded family-planning clinics and trained physicians to perform sterilizations. These policies developed alongside growing concerns about poverty, unemployment, and perceived overpopulation. After World War II, Puerto Rico pursued Operated Bootstrap, an economic development strategy that sought to transform the island from an agricultural economy into an industrial, export-based economy by attracting outside investment. Population growth was also treated as an obstacle to improving living standards, connecting family planning with economic development.
Sterilization consequently became unusually accessible and heavily institutionalized. Between 1957 and 1963, privately operated family-planning clinics funded approximately 11,000 sterilizations. Hospitals and physicians were reimbursed for performing the procedures. By 1965, demographer Harriet Presser estimated that approximately one-third of Puerto Rican mothers between ages twenty and forty-nine had been sterilized. Sterilization became the single largest contributor to the island’s declining fertility rate.
Women also encountered significant barriers to meaningful informed consent. Scholars have documented cases in which sterilization was presented during childbirth or under circumstances that made refusal difficult. One hospital reportedly conditioned admission for delivery for some women with three or more children on accepting sterilization. Puerto Rican physician and reproductive-rights advocate Dr. Helen Rodríguez Trías became a leading critic of sterilization abuse and inadequate consent procedures. Her advocacy helped produce stronger federal sterilization guidelines designed to ensure that consent was voluntary and informed.
Unequal Redress and the Importance of a Paper Trail
Both places illustrate different mechanisms of reproductive control. North Carolina placed government officials between an individual and her reproductive autonomy through petitions, hearings, and orders. Puerto Rico operated a broader level with law, public policy, economic development, and medical institutions shaping the reproductive choices available to an entire population. Such distinct systems, unsurprisingly, produced very different paths toward accountability.
In 2013, North Carolina created a $10 million compensation fund for qualifying survivors who were involuntarily sterilized under the Eugenics Board. The program was limited: claimants had to be alive on June 30, 2013, and claims were due by June 30, 2014. Even with this absurd turnaround requirement, it represents something that Puerto Rican survivors have not received: formal compensation designed specifically to address sterilization abuse.
Puerto Rico should not simply copy North Carolina’s compensation program. Since the island’s sterilization system operated through a broader network of public policy, hospitals, physicians, and family-planning programs, eligibility for compensation should not depend on proving that a government board formally ordered the procedure. Instead, Puerto Rico could establish a commission to collect medical and government records, preserve survivor testimony, and determine when sterilization occurred without meaningful informed consent. That process could provide the foundation for both formal acknowledgement and financial compensation.
Puerto Rico’s territorial status makes the absence of redress especially significant. Puerto Ricans lack of voting representation in the federal government underscores the unequal relationship in which these policies developed. North Carolina demonstrates that governments can acknowledge reproductive injustice decades later, and Puerto Rico should have the same opportunity for recognition and reparations before it is too late.
Accountability was never meant to depend on which system leaves a better paper trail.
Nyla Patel
Class of 2028, Staff Member