Parenting Behind Bars: How Prison Resources Determine Whether Incarcerated Parents Keep Their Children
2.6 million children are currently affected by parental incarceration in the United States. In North Carolina, nearly 160,000 children are affected by parental incarceration. Parental incarceration is known as one type of Adverse Childhood Experiences which may lead to “significant negative impact on child development, future health problems, and criminal behaviors and criminal justice involvement.”
Parental incarceration can also take an emotional and psychological toll on the child and can cause “chronic stress, trauma, and ‘difficulties maintaining parent-child relationships.’” Maternal incarceration has also been linked to insecure attachment relationships with new caregivers. Interestingly, when a father is incarcerated, the mother becomes the primary caregiver about 88% of the time. However, when a mother is incarcerated, the father becomes the primary caregiver only 25-40% of the time, leading the majority of children with incarcerated mothers to be taken into State custody.
Once in foster care, “reunification with the incarcerated parent” is determined based on whether the child “has been in foster care for 15 of the past 22 months.” If so, the government will file for the termination of parental rights as established by 111 Stat. 2118 § 103(a)(3)(E). Further, although the North Carolina statute laying the grounds for terminating parental rights does not carve out an exception for or against incarceration, many courts see incarceration as an inability to care for or raise a child, leading to the fulfillment of the 15 out of 22-month statutory period.
I. In re L.B. Illustration
Recently, the North Carolina Court of Appeals remanded a case in which the lower court terminated a father’s rights purely based on the length of his incarceration. In In re L.B, the Court of Appeals stated that “incarceration, standing alone, is neither a sword nor a shield in termination of parental rights.” Further, the Court found that the trial court’s reliance on incarceration alone to terminate the respondent’s parental rights despite the father doing “everything he could to stay involved in his daughter’s life” was an error. The court highlighted that incarceration significantly limits the resources that parents have to prove to the state that they are trying to make progress in their case plans.
In In re L.B., the father’s case plan included attending substance abuse classes, parenting and anger management courses, mental health treatment, drug education courses, and more, all while being incarcerated. The Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) social worker on his case did not investigate the resources available to the father while in prison, nor did DHHS give the father the case plan and steps needed to keep his parental rights.
II. The Problem
The father continuously communicated with the DHHS workers, sent letters to his child, participated in his child’s medical treatment, and received updates on his child from the paternal grandmother. However, DHHS still moved for adoption and termination of parental rights because the father “could not make much progress on the housing, employment or visitation aspect of his case plan because of his incarceration.” Unfortunately, the trial court agreed with this characterization and recommendation from DHHS and terminated the father’s parental rights.
The decision in In re L.B. highlights the gap between what a case plan demands and what a prison provides and shows that DHHS is not privy to or understanding of these resource constraints. A parent facing termination must show “reasonable progress” in their case plan, yet incarceration limits nearly every means of showing progress. Courts may no longer terminate rights on incarceration alone, but the state will keep finding “lack of progress” for incarcerated parents unless prisons can offer and document the services these case plans require.
Additionally, case plans are not available in every prison. A parent who is willing to follow a case plan to continue having a relationship with their child may not be able to do so because these programs are either unavailable or have long waitlists. Wait times are incredibly important because the termination clock runs regardless of access (under the 15 of 22-month benchmark).
III. Moving Forward
Prisons need to be partners in reunification. At a minimum, prisons should provide access to the core programs case plans commonly require. Additionally, there should be reliable documentation of participation in those programs, and a designated liaison who can communicate with DHHS about available programs, as well as how inmates/parents can access that information. A parent should not lose their child because a program is unavailable. When services are unavailable, courts should consider that the state’s failure to show “reasonable efforts” or “reasonable progress,” rather than counting it against the parent.
Lastly, even with better resources, some terminations will occur. Some children will be adopted, especially when parents face lengthy sentences (for example: in In re L.B., the father was sentenced to a minimum of 10 years in prison). When this occurs, incarcerated parents should be able to seek an enforceable right to continue contact with their child, even after the child is adopted.
Because parental incarceration is an Adverse Childhood Experience, a termination order designed to give the child permanence can also sever the very attachment the child is struggling to preserve. When an incarcerated parent has remained engaged, like the father in In re L.B, post-adoption contact does not undermine permeance. Adoptive parents can keep full legal authority over their child, and contact can be structured around the child’s needs. Overall, parents who do what they can to preserve the parent-child relationship should not lose every connection to their child just because of the limitations imposed by incarceration.
Misrak Murphy
Class of 2028, Staff Member