A System of Unequal Access: Civil Filing Fees, Police Responses, and Domestic Violence Court in North Carolina
Access to justice depends on more than whether a courthouse is open. Observations during a summer legal internship in one of North Carolina’s Domestic Violence (DV) Courts revealed overcrowded court dockets that included disputes that did not appear to involve domestic violence. These observations raise questions about how financial barriers to civil litigation and the guidance individuals receive when seeking assistance may contribute to the use of DV Court for disputes that are better addressed elsewhere.
Filing fees and improper guidance may determine whether an individual is able to bring their claim before the appropriate court. When individuals are met with substantial upfront fees and are experiencing a civil dispute that is misguided to DV Court, that court becomes an unintended substitute for access to civil remedies. Free access to DV court is not the problem; it is essential. The problem is that a system has been created where the public has very few realistic paths to relief, burdening DV court to fill a gap it was not created to fill.
Monetary Barrier
It is very common for ordinary, private citizens to represent themselves in civil court because they cannot afford an attorney. These cases are filed and paid for by private individuals. Every “case type involves the up-front payment of initial filing fees to start the case,” and many cases necessitate additional fees as the case progresses, such as a fee to have a hearing on a motion.
In North Carolina, the Magistrate’s Court, District Court, and Superior Court cost at least $96.00 to file, plus an additional $30 service fee for service by a sheriff. This does not include any additional fees, meaning a civil case will typically cost an individual a minimum of $126.00 before they even appear in court.
An individual may apply for a fee waiver by claiming indigent status–one can do so by showing that they are a recipient of SNAP, Supplemental Security Income, or Temporary Assistance for Needy Families. They may also show that they are represented by a “legal services organization that has as its primary purpose the furnishing of legal services to indigent persons,” or by asserting that they are not a recipient of any of the above but are still unable to afford filing costs. This last option brings additional bureaucratic steps, such as attaching an affidavit of the individual’s income, which may dissuade individuals from completing the application. Even if an individual qualifies for indigent status, “the court still must track the costs that are due, and they might be collected at a later date.” Filing and pursuing a claim in a North Carolina Civil court comes with a substantial monetary barrier.
Misguidance
Law enforcement officers often encounter non-criminal disputes. While they are not responsible for diffusing every conflict between heated parties, their guidance can influence the individuals’ next steps.
Police are broadly responsible for “enforcing laws, maintaining public order, and managing public safety.” Policies vary by department, but many have similar directives to “assist at the scene of civil disputes with the primary goal of safeguarding persons and property, preventing criminal activity and maintaining the peace, …give consideration to all sides, and refrain from giving legal or inappropriate advice.”
One officer’s published post in “Police Magazine” on responding to civil disputes reflects a dismissive attitude toward these calls, referring to the individuals as “these people” and “annoying.” He goes on to carp that civil disputes “[are not] a police matter to begin with.” While an individual commentator’s perspective cannot establish how frequently officers misguide members of the public, this does raise questions about what sort of guidance individuals receive when law enforcement decides that the call they have responded to is a civil matter rather than criminal conduct.
From observing DV Court, it appeared that for “low level” disputes, law enforcement officers often offloaded their duty to meaningfully engage with the public by guiding individuals to file for a Civil Protection Order in DV Court when the dispute at hand does not meet the statutory requirements to succeed in DV Court .
The concern is whether inadequate guidance, combined with the monetary barrier, may leave individuals pursuing remedies that cannot address their underlying disputes.
Impact: Domestic Violence Court is Filling a Gap it is Not Designed to Fill
Pursuant to 34 U.S.C. § 10450, filings in DV court are free. The Violence Against Women Act removed filing fees for protective orders in jurisdictions that receive funding from the STOP Violence Against Women Formula Grant. All States receive this funding, thus, victims do not pay to file in any state.
The monetary contrast with ordinary civil litigation raises an important concern. Individuals facing upfront costs and procedural uncertainty may gravitate toward filing for a protective order without understanding whether their complaint satisfies its statutory requirements. An unsuccessful claim does not necessarily indicate bad faith or that the underlying concern is insignificant. It may instead reflect a mismatch between the relief sought and the legal remedy available.
These barriers may prevent individuals with valid civil claims from obtaining relief while diverting judicial resources from the cases DV Court is designed to address. When DV Court is the most accessible avenue for seeking relief, financial constraints and inadequate guidance from law enforcement may incentivize individuals to pursue remedies that do not satisfy the statutory requirements.
If these filings affect the time and attention judges are able to devote to individuals seeking protection from abuse, this raises serious questions about the system’s ability to provide timely and meaningful access to justice.
DV Court must remain accessible to those who need protection, but it should not have to compensate for the financial and informational barriers elsewhere in the civil justice system. In addressing these barriers, North Carolina may consider improving public-facing information about available civil remedies and promote court-navigational resources.
Jane-Kathryn Whittington
Class of 2028, Staff Member